Security

Lenovo's "encrypted" FU100 USB stick held a plain SD card

Key takeaways

  • Lenovo's ThinkPlus FU100 was sold as AES-256 encrypted, but the fingerprint reader only switched the USB connection on and nothing on the card was encrypted
  • AI-assisted reverse engineering broke several other vendors' protection schemes, finding fixed keys, a certificate-based key and hidden backdoor accounts
  • Lenovo's remedy covers the FU100, FU200, TU800 and TSD303 but requires calling a China service line, then a replacement or on-site firmware upgrade
  • Researcher Xusheng Li says security claims should always be verified independently, because "hardware security" can be pure marketing

A Lenovo fingerprint USB stick sold as AES-256 encrypted turned out to contain an ordinary, unencrypted SD card, which makes it trivial for anyone with physical access to get at the drive's data. Security researcher Xusheng Li found that the ThinkPlus FU100's fingerprint reader only switched the USB connection on. Nothing on the card was encrypted. His blunt takeaway was that "hardware security" can be pure marketing.

What changed

Li presented the FU100 findings in a March conference talk, calling the drive "just an SD card in a fancy case". The original analysis took place last year, and an interim fix involved epoxy over the card.

Lenovo's later fix, put out early this year, covers the FU100, FU200 and TU800 drives, plus the TSD303 SSD. It requires owners to call a China service line, then either send the device back for replacement or get an on-site firmware upgrade. Lenovo advises backing up data first and strongly recommends wiping the drive before sending it in, which is quite an inconvenience. Lenovo rated the advisory's severity as high. One of its three CVEs covers the configuration software, which could let a local, logged-in user bypass device authentication and enrol an untrusted fingerprint.

The same research turned up a different flaw in Lenovo's TSD303 external SSD. Its data actually was encrypted, but the drive sent the correct password back over USB in plain text for the software to compare, making it easy to capture. The first fix for that flaw came three months after the initial report. It used block cipher encryption with a key derived from a timestamp-like value. Lenovo's software could derive that key, and the first software fix is vulnerable if taken apart, which makes it not useful for protecting data if a device is stolen. A later fix, late last year, has the drive check the typed password itself, so the correct one never leaves the drive.

The same software development kit used for the drive covered nine other devices from multiple vendors, most of which could also reveal passwords to a savvy actor. In addition, two left data unencrypted on a microSD card. The full list of vendors was blacked out on Li's slides.

Impact on businesses

For organisations, the FU100 case is a reminder that a "secure" label on removable storage is a claim about the product, not proof of how it works. On the FU100, the card inside was not encrypted, so anyone with physical access to the drive can get to its data.

Lenovo's remedy asks a lot of owners. Calling a China service line, then either sending the device back for replacement or getting an on-site firmware upgrade, is a multi-step route, and Lenovo strongly recommends wiping the drive before sending it in, after backing up the data first. The advisory covers the FU100, FU200 and TU800 drives and the TSD303 SSD, so anyone holding any of those models is in scope.

The configuration software issue adds a further angle. One of the three CVEs in the advisory could let a local, logged-in user bypass device authentication and enrol an untrusted fingerprint, and Lenovo rated the advisory's severity as high.

Using OpenAI's Codex, an AI programming-centric tool, alongside his employer's reverse-engineering tool, he tested other vendors' protection schemes. Copy protection differs from direct access, as the intent is to allow the recipient to view files, just not make copies of them. Netac's tool took about seven minutes to break, as Codex found a fixed key built into the program, along with the user's password written to diagnostic logs. KakaSoft's USB Copy Protection has an internal password the program builds itself, which Codex rebuilt to decrypt a test file without the user's password in around 26 minutes. Nexcopy's Copy Secure took about 10 minutes, with its key unlocked by a certificate built into the viewer app. Separately, SecZure's YutianDun has two hidden "backdoor" accounts with simple passwords, discovered with time-travel debugging, which steps through a timeline trace.

Li's comments suggest that malicious intent cannot be assumed.

Impact on consumers and users

Owners of the affected Lenovo models face the service route Lenovo describes. The company advises backing up data first and strongly recommends wiping the drive before sending it in, which is quite an inconvenience.

The TSD303 SSD is a different case from the FU100. Its data actually was encrypted, but the drive sent the correct password back over USB in plain text for the software to compare, making it easy to capture. The later fix has the drive check the typed password itself, so the correct one never leaves the drive.

For everyday users, Li's advice is the most practical guidance on offer: always verify security claims on your own, rather than relying on what a product's packaging says.

Impact on the wider industry

Li gave no warning to KakaSoft, Nexcopy or SecZure, arguing that a drive already in an attacker's hands cannot easily be recalled or updated. Netac had no patch as of Li's March talk.

His technical conclusion is stark: "client-side validation is never secure". He also said that security claims should always be verified independently.

Li's tests also showed how widely the weaknesses reach. The software development kit used for the drive covered nine other devices from multiple vendors, most of which could also reveal passwords, and two left data unencrypted on a microSD card. The AI-assisted attacks on Netac, KakaSoft and Nexcopy took about seven, 26 and 10 minutes respectively, and the flaws involved were a fixed key built into a program, a password written to diagnostic logs, an internal password the program builds itself and a key unlocked by a certificate in the viewer app.

A comment under the Tom's Hardware report argued that selling a device as encrypted when it is not is already illegal false advertising.

There is a counterexample of things done right. An open-source USB stick does encryption properly, even though it is built on a microSD card, deriving its key from the user's password, so reading the card alone gets an attacker nothing. That design stands in direct contrast to the FU100, where the card inside was a plain, unencrypted SD card.

What comes next

Netac had no patch as of Li's March talk. The full list of vendors covered by the shared software development kit was blacked out on his slides.

For the Lenovo products, the later fix for the FU100, FU200, TU800 and TSD303 remains the route Lenovo has set out: a call to a China service line, then replacement or an on-site firmware upgrade.

AI agent use for driving reverse-engineering tools continues to increase, and AI has also been exposing more security flaws recently. Li's work with Codex on Netac, KakaSoft and Nexcopy is one example of that trend.

Verdict

The FU100 flaw is a serious one for people who trusted the drive's label, because the card inside was not encrypted, although Lenovo has since set out a remedy involving a call to a China service line, a back-up and a wipe. The research also carries a clear lesson, in Li's own words: always verify security claims on your own.

Frequently asked questions

Which Lenovo drives are covered by the advisory?

Lenovo's fix covers the FU100, FU200 and TU800 drives as well as the TSD303 SSD. Owners must call a China service line, then send the device back for replacement or get an on-site firmware upgrade.

What should be done before sending a drive back?

Lenovo advises backing up data first and strongly recommends wiping the drive before sending it in.

More from Future Technology HQ