iCloud public links: Apple to scan "Anyone with the Link" shares
Key takeaways
- Items shared with "Anyone with the Link" will be checked by Apple for harmful content from version 27.3
- Sharing by public link disables end-to-end encryption, even with Advanced Data Protection switched on
- Apple has not defined "harmful content" or said whether humans, automation or both do the checking
- IT teams should review whether staff use public iCloud links for work files
Apple has said it will check iCloud items shared through public links for "harmful content", and that sharing this way strips them of end-to-end encryption. The change arrives with version 27.3 of iOS, iPadOS, macOS and visionOS, according to a support page Apple published on Tuesday.
What Apple's public link scanning actually is
iCloud lets users share photos in iCloud Photos or files in iCloud Drive in two broad ways: directly with named people, or through a link set to "Anyone with the Link". The new checks apply only to the second route. Apple's help page says: "Items shared using Anyone with the Link will be checked by Apple for harmful content."
End-to-end encryption, where only the sender and recipient hold the keys needed to read data, is the key detail. Apple says choosing the public-link option removes that protection from the shared item. That holds even when the account owner has switched on Advanced Data Protection, Apple's optional setting that applies end-to-end encryption to supported iCloud data such as backups, photos and notes. Apple also says it can itself access content shared this way.
How it is meant to work
Apple has not said. The company has not explained whether human moderators, automated systems or both will do the checking, or whether AI will make any of the calls. Nor has it said whether links created before the 27.3 updates ship will be checked retroactively. The Hacker News notes it is also unclear what prompted the change.
A useful analogy: end-to-end encrypted sharing is a sealed envelope handed to a named person. A public link is a postcard left on a noticeboard. Anyone with the address can read it, and the noticeboard's owner can read it too. Apple is now saying it will check the postcards.
What happens after a check is clearer. Apple says it reserves the right to "move, refuse, modify, remove, or delete the content at any time". It may block or disable the Apple Account involved, block creation of a new account tied to the same email address or phone number, and involve law enforcement "if necessary".
Who is affected and why it matters
Anyone who uses public iCloud links is affected: individuals sending holiday photos to relatives, freelancers handing over drafts, small businesses circulating documents without a managed file-sharing tool. The change is less about people who share directly with named contacts.
The wording at the centre of the criticism is "harmful content". Apple's mention of law enforcement suggests the category could cover child sexual abuse material, malware and other unlawful content, but the support page does not say so. The Register argues that without a definition, users are left at Apple's discretion, and raises the prospect of content being removed to suit political pressure. That is the publication's view rather than anything Apple has stated.
What the limitations are
The scope is narrow but the uncertainty is wide. The checks cover only public-link shares, so direct shares to named people appear unaffected. Against that, Apple has given no detail on accuracy, appeals, or what happens to wrongly flagged material. The Register notes automated moderation can easily be fooled into a bad call. Apple did not respond to its questions.
The UK angle
Apple's page covers iOS, iPadOS, macOS and visionOS, but neither source says whether rollout differs by region. Neither source mentions any UK regulator or UK-specific rules. For organisations, the relevant frame is data protection. A member of staff who shares a customer spreadsheet through an "Anyone with the Link" iCloud URL has put that file outside end-to-end encryption and within reach of Apple's checks.
What this means in practice
A concrete example: a small design agency sends a client a link to a folder of unreleased campaign images, set to "Anyone with the Link". Once shared that way, those images are no longer end-to-end encrypted and Apple can access them, even if every employee has Advanced Data Protection on; whether links created before 27.3 are checked is unclear.
Practical steps follow from what Apple has said about public links:
- Share directly with named people where confidentiality matters, rather than using public links.
- Audit existing public links, since Apple has not said whether older ones will be checked.
- Treat any public-link item as unencrypted and readable by the provider.
- For business use, set a policy on which tools staff may use for sharing client or personal data.
Where this is heading
The beta reaches developers now, with the general release expected in December. Until then, the open questions are the ones Apple has not answered: a definition of harmful content, how decisions are made and by whom, and whether existing links are caught. Apple's support page is the document to watch for amendments before the release lands.
Frequently asked questions
Will Apple scan all my iCloud files?
Based on Apple's wording, the checks apply to items shared using "Anyone with the Link", not content shared directly with other people. Apple has not said how the checks work.
Does Advanced Data Protection stop the scanning?
No. Apple says sharing an item with "Anyone with the Link" disables end-to-end encryption for that item, even if Advanced Data Protection is enabled.
When does the change start?
It begins with version 27.3 of iOS, iPadOS, macOS and visionOS. Those releases reached developers in beta on Tuesday, with a general release expected in December.
What is "harmful content" under Apple's policy?
Apple has not defined it. It says it may move, refuse, modify, remove or delete content, block accounts, and involve law enforcement where necessary.