Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook gallery suggestions
Key takeaways
- Italy fined Meta €805m ($887m) because Facebook's Android app reached users' photo galleries without specific consent or clear information
- The feature at issue, gallery suggestions, has been available since 2023 and affected about 20 million Android users in Italy
- Meta must now ask for consent through a separate, specific request that says what the access is for and how to switch it off
- Meta says it will appeal and strongly disagrees with the fine
Italy's data protection agency has fined Meta €805m ($887m) because the Facebook app on Android reached into users' photo galleries without asking for specific consent. The case turns on a narrow question with wide consequences: when does a single permission prompt count as consent for everything an app later does with it?
What Facebook's gallery suggestions actually are
The feature at the centre of the case is called gallery suggestions. It has been available since 2023 and offers photos and videos from a user's phone gallery as ideas for posts while they browse Facebook. The Guardian describes it as suggesting photos and videos from the phone's gallery as ideas for posts.
Italy's regulator said that in doing so, Facebook accessed "photographs, videos and related metadata belonging to Italian users without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them". Metadata is the descriptive data attached to a file, which in a photo can include details such as when and where it was taken.
How the consent flow fell short
According to the regulator, Facebook asked for gallery access through a single authorisation valid for the entire app. That request came after a generic notice asking users to enable other features. Users could not tell, the authority said, that they were also authorising suggestions drawn from their gallery.
The regulator's remedy is specific. Meta must now seek consent through a separate request for the feature concerned. It must signpost clearly what the access is used for, namely that it involves a user's photo gallery, and how to disable it.
How the fine was calculated
The authority listed what pushed the figure up. It took into account the high number of people affected, about 20 million Android users in Italy. It cited the duration of the infringement, which it said is still ongoing for those who have not updated the app and for those who have already given their consent to the system. It also pointed to Meta's lack of cooperation during the investigation.
The Guardian reports the fine as roughly 0.4% of the group's annual turnover, which hit $201bn in 2025, for a net profit of $60.5bn. It is among the largest an Italian authority has imposed on a tech company. In 2021, Amazon received a fine of more than €1.1bn for breaching competition law, later reduced to €752m on appeal. Meta has said it will appeal. A company spokesperson said "we strongly disagree" with the assessment by the regulators "and the disproportionate level of the fine".
Separately, in late October, authorities in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25bn for misleading the state's residents for more than a decade about the use of their data, which Meta slammed as a "tax" on freedom of expression.
What the limitations of the ruling are
The fine is not final. Meta's appeal could change the amount, as happened with Amazon.
The objection is to how permission was sought and described, not to the existence of the feature.
What this means in practice
For UK readers, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) is the regulator that applies data protection law here, under the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018. Nothing in the Italian decision says the ICO has acted against Meta, and this ruling does not bind it. The ICO's guide to data security is a useful reference for organisations assessing how apps handle personal data.
For IT teams and developers, the practical lessons are plain:
- Request sensitive permissions, such as gallery access, at the point of use and for a named purpose, not as part of a blanket prompt.
- Say what the access is for in the prompt itself.
- Make the setting easy to find and to switch off.
- Treat a consent granted for one feature as covering that feature only.
For users and device managers, it is worth reviewing which apps hold photo and media permissions on company and personal Android phones, especially for guidance on checking whether a phone is being monitored. Apps that were granted broad access years ago may be using it in ways the original prompt never described.
Where this is heading
Meta must now seek consent through a separate, specific request for gallery suggestions, and it has said it will appeal. The detail to watch is the regulator's insistence on a separate, feature-specific request, because that standard, if it holds, applies to any app that bundles permissions behind one prompt. Developers should expect scrutiny of that pattern to continue.
Frequently asked questions
Why was Meta fined in Italy?
Italy's data protection agency said Facebook's Android app accessed users' photos, videos and metadata without specific consent and without properly informing them, through its gallery suggestions feature.
How much is the Meta fine?
The fine is €805m, reported as $887m. The Guardian reports it as roughly 0.4% of Meta's annual turnover, which hit $201bn in 2025.
How many people were affected by the Facebook gallery feature?
The authority said about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, and cited that number when setting the size of the fine.
Will Meta appeal the Italian fine?
Yes. A Meta spokesperson said the company strongly disagrees with the assessment and the disproportionate level of the fine, and that it will appeal.