Trump and Congress say the AI industry is overreacting to its own warnings
Key takeaways
- Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson publicly dismissed AI industry warnings about existential risk
- Anthropic's Dario Amodei called for labs to 'pace the frontier', with Sam Altman and Elon Musk publicly agreeing
- Johnson said an emergency push by Congress to regulate AI would mean losing the race to China
- Trump called fears that AI will destroy the world a "hoax" in a series of Truth Social posts
Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei has called on the AI industry to slow down, and OpenAI's Sam Altman and Elon Musk publicly agreed with him. The US government's response was, in effect: relax. President Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson both pushed back, arguing that the real priority is keeping America ahead of China.
That makes for an unusual political moment. Some of the most powerful figures in AI are asking for a slower pace, and a Republican administration that has encouraged the industry's rapid growth is telling them they are overreacting.
What the industry said
On Saturday 12 September, Amodei published a blog post titled "We Must Pace the Frontier", arguing for slower development of AI models to "reduce the risk that something goes seriously wrong". Altman and Musk both voiced their support on X, and The Verge reports that Alphabet's Demis Hassabis offered tentative support for the proposal too.
The call came days after a former Anthropic researcher, Jacob Coxon, quit and warned that the technology could "kill us all by the end of the decade", accusing both OpenAI and Anthropic of "gambling with our lives", according to CNBC.
The government's counter-argument
Trump's case is that slowing down would hand China the advantage. "Look, we're leading China in AI ... and, frankly, I want to keep it that way, because whoever wins AI, wins," he said, according to the Financial Times, as cited by The Verge.
On Monday 14 September he went further in a run of Truth Social posts, calling himself the "Hoax Buster" and describing fears that AI will "take over, consume, and destroy the World" as a hoax. "Concerning AI, when, in the History of Business, did anyone see the Leaders of an Industry call for Regulation that, if strongly implemented, will drive them into oblivion and bankruptcy?" he wrote. He also claimed the government already has "tremendous CRIMINAL and REGULATORY power over these companies".
Johnson made a similar argument on CNN's State of the Union. "If Congress just races in and does some sort of emergency session to try to regulate AI, we will lose the race to China, that is a threat to every single American," he told Jake Tapper. "We don't need everybody to panic right now."
The White House AI czar, David Sacks, also pushed back, writing on X that the companies should "go ahead and pace the frontier" themselves and "stop pretending the motivation to slow down is purely altruistic". He added that China would be "very unlikely" to join a global agreement to regulate the technology.
Why this matters beyond the politics
The China argument is not absurd: there is a real geopolitical dimension to who builds the most capable models first. But it treats AI development as a straightforward race, where the only thing that matters is getting there first. The safety argument Amodei is making is that winning that race means little if the systems cannot be kept under control.
In the short term, the split makes federal action unlikely. CNBC reports that any attempt at AI regulation by Congress appears highly unlikely before the 3 November midterm elections, with House members due to spend October in their districts. That leaves the debate about how fast frontier labs should move largely in the hands of the labs themselves, which are also the ones that would decide whether any slowdown actually happens.
Whether you think AI poses an existential risk or think that framing is overblown, the fact that this argument is now playing out in public between the White House and the heads of the biggest AI labs is significant.