# Passkeys vs security keys: which accounts still need a YubiKey

> Passkeys and hardware security keys both stop phishing. Here is where they differ, which accounts need a key, UK prices and how to set one up safely.

- Published: 2026-10-02
- Updated: 2026-10-28
- Topic: [Security](https://futuretechnologyhq.com/topic/security/)
- URL: https://futuretechnologyhq.com/article/passkeys-vs-security-keys-yubikey/
- Publisher: [Future Technology HQ](https://futuretechnologyhq.com/), free to read. Quote as "Future Technology HQ" with a link to the article.

## Key points

- Synced passkeys and hardware security keys both use FIDO2, so both resist phishing; the difference is where the private key lives and whether it can ever be copied.
- The NCSC now recommends passkeys wherever a service offers them, and says the key control for synced passkeys is how well the sync account itself is protected.
- Malware research published in August 2026 showed synced passkeys in Google Password Manager on Windows could be abused or exposed once malware was already on the PC. A hardware key never releases its private key.
- Put hardware keys on the two or three accounts that can reset everything else, usually email, your Apple or Google account and your password manager. Use synced passkeys everywhere else.
- Buy two keys. On Yubico's UK store a FIDO-only Security Key costs £30 and a YubiKey 5 NFC costs £60, so a pair starts at £60.

## Article

*This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you. [Full disclosure](/affiliate-disclosure/).*

A passkey and a hardware security key do the same job: both use the FIDO2 standard to sign you in without a password, and both resist phishing. The difference is storage. A synced passkey lives in a cloud keychain and copies to your devices; a security key keeps its private key inside one physical device that cannot export it.

For most accounts a synced passkey is enough. For the two or three accounts that can reset everything else, a pair of hardware keys costing from £60 is still the stronger choice. This guide explains why, shows which threats each method stops, and gives the exact setup steps for Apple, Google and Microsoft accounts.

## What is the difference between a passkey and a security key?

Both are built on FIDO2 and WebAuthn. When you register, your device creates a key pair: the website stores the public key and the private key stays with you. At sign-in the website sends a challenge, your device signs it, and the site checks the signature. The signature is tied to the real web address, so a lookalike phishing site receives nothing it can replay. The FIDO Alliance describes passkeys as phishing-resistant for exactly this reason.

Where the private key sits is what separates them:

- **Synced passkeys** are stored in iCloud Keychain, Google Password Manager, a Microsoft account or a password manager such as 1Password or Bitwarden. They copy to every device signed in to that account, so losing a phone does not lose the passkey.
- **Device-bound passkeys on a security key** are generated inside tamper-resistant hardware and never leave it. Your computer asks the key to sign; the key returns only the signature.

The US standards body NIST makes the same distinction in its digital identity guidelines, SP 800-63B-4. Syncable authenticators can meet its AAL2 level, but because syncing means the key is exportable, they do not meet AAL3, the highest level, which requires a non-exportable key. In plain terms: synced passkeys move the security boundary to your cloud account and every device signed into it. A hardware key keeps it on your keyring.

## What does the NCSC recommend in the UK?

On 23 April 2026 the National Cyber Security Centre said it will recommend passkeys wherever a service supports them, with two-step verification (2SV) as the fallback where it does not. Its blog states that FIDO2 credentials, including passkeys, are as secure as or more secure than traditional multi-factor authentication against common attacks, and that traditional methods such as SMS codes are "inherently phishable".

On syncing, the NCSC's view is that it is not a new kind of risk, because people already trust cloud sync for email and password managers. It adds that "the key control is the strength of the authentication protecting the sync account". That sentence is the case for a hardware key in miniature: put the strongest sign-in you have on the account that holds all your other passkeys.

## Which threats does each sign-in method stop?

This table compares the four common second factors against the threats that actually take over personal accounts. "Partly" means the method helps but has a known gap.

| Threat | SMS code | Authenticator app code | Synced passkey | Hardware security key |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phishing page that relays your login in real time | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| SIM swap or number port-out | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Password reuse or data breach | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Malware already on your computer | No | No | Partly: keys can be abused or exposed on a compromised PC | Partly: malware may trick you into one tap, but cannot copy the key |
| Takeover of your Apple, Google or password manager account | No | No | No: the passkeys sync to the attacker | Yes: the key is not in the cloud |
| Lost or stolen phone | Partly | Partly | Yes, if your account recovery is sound | Yes, if you registered a spare |
| Someone who can coerce you or has your unlocked device | No | No | No | No |

Two rows explain most of the decision. A hardware key is the only option that survives a takeover of your cloud account, and it is the only one whose private key cannot leave the device even on an infected PC. No method protects you against someone who can physically force you to sign in. If that is your situation, see our guide to [checking whether your phone is being monitored](/article/how-to-check-if-your-phone-is-monitored/), which includes UK support contacts.

## What did the 2026 passkey attack research show?

Three pieces of research published in early August 2026 looked at passkeys on Windows. None broke the FIDO2 cryptography, and every one needed malware already running on the victim's computer.

**Unit 42 (Palo Alto Networks), "Pass-ta-key".** Published on 3 August, it described three ways malware on a Windows PC could abuse Google Password Manager's synced passkeys in Chrome. The most serious, called Golden Pass-ta-key, targets the security domain secret, the master key that protects a user's synced passkeys. According to BleepingComputer's report, Google removed the secret from logs after disclosure, but Unit 42 says it is still briefly present in Chrome's process memory. Unit 42 did not report exploitation in the wild.

**SpecterOps, "Pass-the-Passkey".** Presented at Black Hat USA on 5 August, this showed Windows had been writing complete WebAuthn sign-in signatures to event logs that an unprivileged user could read. Microsoft fixed the logging issue as CVE-2026-34348 in its July 2026 updates by truncating the logged signature. SpecterOps also reported weaknesses in how Microsoft Entra ID validated challenges, which it said were still open when it published.

**Dirk-jan Mollema.** He showed that malware running in a signed-in Windows session could use a Windows Hello for Business key to authenticate to Entra ID without a fresh PIN or biometric prompt. The Hacker News found no CVE or Microsoft advisory for it as of 6 August.

The common thread is that once malware is on your machine, keys held in software can be abused or copied. A hardware key's private key cannot be exported, although malware can still try to get you to approve a sign-in you did not intend. Keeping Windows, macOS and your browser updated matters as much as the key itself.

## Which accounts should get a hardware key?

Use synced passkeys wherever they are offered. Add hardware keys to the short list of accounts that can reset or unlock the rest:

- **Your main email account.** Almost every password reset lands there.
- **Your Apple Account or Google Account.** These hold your synced passkeys, so a key here protects the vault itself.
- **Your password manager**, if it supports FIDO2 sign-in.
- **Anything that holds money or admin rights:** work admin accounts, cloud consoles and domain registrars.

At work, the change may come to you. Microsoft's Entra documentation says that from 1 September 2026 users enabled for SMS or voice codes are automatically enabled and prompted to register a passkey, and Microsoft-provided SMS and voice delivery retires on 1 February 2027 for most users (1 July 2027 for Global Administrators and external users). If your employer uses Microsoft 365, ask IT whether a hardware key is an approved option.

## How much does a security key cost in the UK?

Prices below are from Yubico's UK store, including VAT, checked on 11 October 2026. Yubico's store lists current stock at firmware 5.8. Google sells Titan keys through the Google Store in the UK but its price was not verifiable at the time of writing, so check it before buying.

| Key | What it does | Price each (UK) | Pair of two |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yubico Security Key NFC (USB-A) or Security Key C NFC (USB-C) | FIDO2 and U2F only | £30 | £60 |
| YubiKey 5 NFC (USB-A) or YubiKey 5C NFC (USB-C) | FIDO2, U2F, OTP, smart card (PIV), OpenPGP, OATH codes | £60 | £120 |
| Mixed pair: one Security Key plus one YubiKey 5 | FIDO2 on both, extras on one | £30 and £60 | £90 |
| Google Titan Security Key (USB-A/NFC or USB-C/NFC) | FIDO2 and U2F, up to 250 passkeys | Check current price | Check current price |

For a personal account, the FIDO-only Security Key does everything you need. The YubiKey 5 is worth the extra £30 only if you need one-time codes, smart card sign-in at work, SSH or OpenPGP keys. Yubico says YubiKey 5 Series keys on firmware 5.7 or later store up to 100 passkeys, up from 25, and firmware cannot be upgraded, so buy from a seller with current stock if you plan to store many. Google says the current Titan generation stores up to 250 passkeys.

[Check UK prices on Amazon: Yubico Security Key C NFC](https://www.amazon.co.uk/s?k=Yubico+Security+Key+C+NFC&tag=futuretech0d6-21)

[Check UK prices on Amazon: YubiKey 5C NFC](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B08DHL1YDL?tag=futuretech0d6-21)

## How do you add a security key to your accounts?

Register both keys on each account in the same sitting, and save backup codes before you finish.

**Apple Account (iPhone or iPad).** Every device signed in to the account needs iOS 16.3, iPadOS 16.3 or macOS Ventura 13.2 or later, and two-factor authentication must be on.

1. Open Settings and tap your name.
2. Tap Sign-in & Security, then Two-Factor Authentication.
3. Tap Security Keys, then Add Security Keys, and follow the prompts. Apple requires at least two keys and allows up to six.
4. Review the list of signed-in devices. Apple signs out devices unused for more than 90 days during setup.

**Google Account.** In Chrome, open Google's security key enrolment page at myaccount.google.com/signinoptions/two-step-verification (Google's help page links straight to the add-key dialog), sign in and follow the prompts. A passkey needs a FIDO2 key; older FIDO U2F keys work only as a second step. Google's help page warns a newly added key can take up to seven days to appear at sign-in. If you want the strictest setup, Google's Advanced Protection Program requires a passkey or security key at every sign-in and adds stricter download and app checks.

**Microsoft account (personal).** Sign in at account.live.com/proofs/manage (Advanced security options), choose to add a new way to sign in, select the face, fingerprint, PIN or security key option, then choose security key and follow the prompts.

**Check it worked.** Sign out in a private browser window and sign back in. You should be asked for the key. Then repeat with the second key so you know both work.

**Remove a lost key.** Apple: Settings, your name, Sign-in & Security, Two-Factor Authentication, Security Keys. Apple's only option there is Remove All Security Keys, which returns the account to six-digit codes; add a replacement pair afterwards, because Apple needs at least two. Google: open 2-Step Verification and select the bin icon next to the key. Microsoft: open Advanced security options, select the key under ways to prove who you are, and choose Remove.

Keep synced passkeys on your phone for daily sign-ins if you like. The hardware keys are the root of trust, not something you need to tap fifty times a day. For the wider picture, our [Android security checklist](/article/android-security-checklist-2026/) and our explainer on [how voice phishing gets people to hand over access](/article/what-is-vishing-how-to-prevent/) cover the attacks that keys alone do not stop.

## What the ICO and UK law say

**The ICO's** guidance on passwords in online services sits under its guide to data security, which says the UK GDPR security principle requires appropriate technical and organisational measures. How people sign in to a system that holds personal data is one of those measures.

**UK law.** UK GDPR Article 32, applied by the Data Protection Act 2018, requires measures appropriate to the risk. In our view, phishing-resistant sign-in for the accounts that can reach personal data is the clearest example of a measure appropriate to today's risk.

## Frequently asked questions

### Is a passkey as safe as a hardware security key?

Against phishing, yes. Both bind the sign-in to the real website, so a fake page gets nothing it can reuse. Against malware already on your computer, a hardware key is stronger, because its private key cannot be exported, while a synced passkey is only as safe as the cloud account and devices it syncs to.

### Can a YubiKey store passkeys?

Yes. YubiKeys and Yubico Security Keys store device-bound passkeys. Yubico says YubiKey 5 Series keys on firmware 5.7 or later hold up to 100, up from 25 on earlier firmware, and firmware cannot be updated after manufacture.

### Do I need two security keys?

Yes. Apple requires at least two before it will turn security keys on for an Apple Account, and every other service is safer with a spare registered. Keep one on your keyring and one at home.

### What happens if I lose my security key?

Sign in with your second key or a backup code, then remove the lost key from every account it was registered on. If you lose every key and every recovery method on an account that requires one, you can be locked out permanently.

*Last checked: 11 October 2026.*

## Sources

- [NCSC: Passkeys are more secure than traditional ways to log in](https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blogs/passkeys-are-more-secure-than-traditional-ways-to-log-in)
- [FIDO Alliance: Passkeys](https://fidoalliance.org/passkeys/)
- [NIST SP 800-63B-4: syncable authenticators](https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-4/sp800-63b/syncable/)
- [Apple Support: About Security Keys for Apple Account](https://support.apple.com/en-gb/102637)
- [Google Account Help: Use a security key for 2-Step Verification](https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/6103523?hl=en-GB)
- [Google Advanced Protection Program](https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/)
- [Microsoft Support: Signing in with a passkey](https://support.microsoft.com/account-billing/signing-in-with-a-passkey-09a49a86-ca47-406c-8acc-ed0e3c852c6d)
- [Yubico UK store](https://www.yubico.com/gb/store/)
- [Yubico: YubiKey 5.7 firmware capacity](https://www.yubico.com/blog/empowering-enterprise-security-at-scale-with-new-product-innovations-yubikey-5-7-and-yubico-authenticator-7/)
- [Google: The latest Titan Security Key](https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/titan-security-key-google-store/)
- [Titan Security Key availability by country](https://support.google.com/titansecuritykey/answer/9115487?hl=en-GB)
- [BleepingComputer: Pass-ta-key attacks on Google-synced passkeys](https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/new-pass-ta-key-attacks-let-malware-hijack-google-synced-passkeys/)
- [The Hacker News: Malware can abuse Windows Hello for Business keys](https://thehackernews.com/2026/08/malware-can-abuse-windows-hello-for.html)
- [Dark Reading: Flaws in passkey implementations](https://www.darkreading.com/identity-access-management-security/flaws-passkeys-implementation-old-attacks-work)
- [Microsoft Entra: passkeys by default and SMS and voice retirement](https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/entra/identity/authentication/concept-sms-voice-retirement)
- [ICO, Passwords in online services](https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/security/a-guide-to-data-security/passwords-in-online-services/)
- [legislation.gov.uk, UK GDPR Article 32, Security of processing](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2016/679/article/32)
