# Little red dots: Webb's QSO1 tested as a primordial black hole

> Johns Hopkins researchers modelled three scenarios for Webb's QSO1 and found a small primordial black hole feeding on gas is the likeliest.

- Published: 2026-11-10
- Topic: [Space](https://futuretechnologyhq.com/topic/space/)
- URL: https://futuretechnologyhq.com/article/little-red-dots-webb-s-qso1-tested-as-a-primordial-black/
- Publisher: [Future Technology HQ](https://futuretechnologyhq.com/), free to read. Quote as "Future Technology HQ" with a link to the article.

## Key points

- Of three scenarios modelled, the likeliest is a small primordial black hole that grew by consuming surrounding gas and energy
- QSO1 is almost entirely hydrogen and helium and dates to 700 million years after the Big Bang
- Proof would need a black hole too light to be astrophysical or old enough to pre-date stars
- The team next plans to examine how many of 100 catalogued little red dots could be primordial

## Article

A new Johns Hopkins study modelled three scenarios, and the most likely way a primordial black hole could become the little red dot known as QSO1 is by starting small and feeding on surrounding gas and energy until it grew to QSO1's size. The work, published in Physical Review Letters, does not prove that primordial black holes exist. It narrows the ways they could.

Primordial black holes are theoretical objects. Unlike ordinary black holes, which are born from the gravitational death of a star, they would come from the physics of the early universe, before the first stars, when space was expanding exponentially. Stephen Hawking first proposed them in the 1970s, and astrophysicists have never found direct evidence for them.

## The headline numbers

| Item | Figure from the study |
|---|---|
| Age of QSO1 | 700 million years after the Big Bang |
| Composition | Almost entirely hydrogen and helium |
| Scenarios modelled | 3 |
| Little red dots catalogued and observed | 100 |
| Likeliest scenario | A smaller primordial black hole grows by consuming surrounding gas and energy |

QSO1, formally Abell 2744-QSO1, is one of the little red dots seen in images from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). These are swirling, super-hot discs of galactic dust particles, energy and gas.

## What the data actually shows

The team chose QSO1 as a proof of concept because it stands out on three counts: its age, its size and its composition. Unlike other little red dots, it lacks the heavier elements that formed later in cosmic history. That chemistry, together with its age and size, is why scientists suspected it could contain a primordial black hole.

Co-author Valerio De Luca frames the core difficulty: little red dots can surround astrophysical black holes, and most probably many of them do, but they could also surround primordial ones. "Which ones are primordial and how can we tell?" is the question the modelling begins to address.

The modelling also had to respect existing limits. Co-author Loris Del Grosso points out that cosmological observations constrain primordial black holes: there can only be so many in the universe, and not too many in a given cluster. A primordial black hole can only grow to QSO1's size and acquire a swirling disc under special circumstances. Within those limits, the researchers tested whether a primordial black hole could plausibly become a little red dot of QSO1's size surrounded by that concentration of other discs. Some scenarios fared better than others, and growth by accretion, a small black hole pulling in gas and energy, came out ahead.

Del Grosso's own summary is measured: "The door was open on this theory, that little red dots could be primordial black holes. We've now cracked it open a little farther by showing some scenarios are more likely than others."

## What the data does not tell us

This is a plausibility test, not a detection. Nothing in the work shows that QSO1 actually contains a primordial black hole. It shows that some scenarios are more likely than others, with one growth route favoured over the other two modelled.

The researchers are explicit about what would settle the matter. Definitive proof would require finding a black hole that is either too light to be an astrophysical black hole, or so old that it pre-dates the existence of stars. QSO1 existing 700 million years after the Big Bang does not meet either bar on its own.

## How this compares

The comparison that matters is between the two origin stories. Astrophysical black holes come from collapsing stars; primordial ones would come from the earliest moments of cosmic history, which De Luca says scientists do not clearly understand. That is why the stakes are higher than a single object's classification. In De Luca's words, if primordial black holes exist, "something had to happen to make them in the first place, which would be a major discovery in physics."

For wider context on what JWST is revealing about the early universe, our report on a [galaxy cluster at cosmic noon that defies growth models](/article/webb-xlssc-122-galaxy-cluster-dark-matter/) shows a similar pattern: Webb data challenging standard assumptions about how structure grew.

## So what?

For astronomers, the immediate task is scale. The team plans to explore how many of the 100 observed and catalogued little red dots could be primordial black holes. A population-level answer would be far more informative than one object.

For everyone else, this is a science story with no product, price or regulatory consequence. The practical point is about how to read it: a plausibility study from Johns Hopkins, backed by funders including the US National Science Foundation and NASA, with co-authors from Padova and the Space Telescope Science Institute, is a step in an argument rather than a conclusion.

The takeaway: QSO1 keeps the primordial black hole idea alive, and a small black hole growing on surrounding gas is the favoured route, but proof still requires a black hole too light, or too old, to be explained by stars.

## Sources

- [Johns Hopkins University via EurekAlert](https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1150962)
- [Space.com](https://www.space.com/astronomy/black-holes/are-the-james-webb-space-telescopes-mysterious-little-red-dots-actually-tiny-black-holes-left-over-from-the-big-bang-era)
